Wheeling Cemetery is located in Pleasant Grove Township Section 5 Township 76 Range 21 at 255 Hwy. 5 in Pleasantville. The parcel number is 1912400100.

 

Well-hidden from the highway, this site of almost 200 burials is 2 miles northwest of Pleasantville and is located at the last remnant of the town of Wheeling. At the mailbox with the 255 street sign, turn onto a paved driveway, and then drive east on a cinder lane flanked on each side with a row of pear trees. Veer right onto the grass, then east and north through a dense forest which opens onto the cemetery. A farm pond lies below the north side.

​

MCPCC members worked on straightening many of the bases and stones in this cemetery in 2017.